True crime documentaries and narratives are intensely popular, particularly on streaming services. Many people, particularly women, report watching this type of documentary for relaxation, much to the amusement of social media (e.g., memes, reels, comedy bits). A plethora of true crime podcasts also exist, and these often get listeners talking "in real time" over radio waves when other subjects may not.
However, fictional crime was a popular genre long before true crime, and remains so. Mystery movies, detective television series, and movies centered on the lives, escapes, and even last days of inmates, garner tons of views, reviews, and discussions every day. Some fictional crime stories, such as The Shawshank Redemption or The Great Escape, have taken their place among "classic" films.
With true and fictional crime getting so much attention, many questions arise. Namely, which type attracts what sort of audience, and why? Is there any overlap, and where does that exist? Perhaps most importantly, is there any way to tell whether true or fictional crime is more appealing?
Analyze this last question in light of the other two, as well as factors such as the nature of the crimes (e.g., "cozy mysteries" vs. "harder" crimes), storytelling choices and mechanics, casting choices, or any other factors you choose. If you choose to gear your argument toward one side or the other, choose some examples to prove why that version is the stronger, more appealing one.
Note: When considering the popularity of true vs. fictional crime, it can be interesting to explore the different psychological pulls they have on audiences. True crime, for instance, seems to satisfy a natural curiosity about real-life dangers and justice, letting viewers safely peek into society’s darker corners. Some people, especially women, say it even helps them feel more prepared or aware, as they learn about survival stories and warning signs. Fictional crime, on the other hand, offers that creative storytelling arc, where we get closure, character growth, and sometimes a bit of social commentary, all within a controlled narrative. It’s a chance to get lost in suspense or empathy without the moral weight that real cases can carry. Depending on what people are looking for—adrenaline, comfort, insight, or just plain entertainment—true and fictional crime each bring something different to the table. – Beatrix Kondo2 weeks ago