Contributing writer for The Artifice.
Junior Contributor I
Zuko, Snape, Eleanor Shellstrop -- What makes a good redemtion arc?Characters that present as villainous at first and nobly heroic nearing the end, have always fascinated audiences. Zuko from Avatar The Last Airbender, presents as a particularly striking example of this. Here we have a young teenager who just fills an antagonist role so well. He constantly is hunting Aang and company in the hopes to restore his honour. As the story progresses however, through various trials, tribulations, self-reflection, and personal development, he ultimately finds his own honour in helping the Avatar. Eleanor from the show The Good Place has a similar arc where self-development, understanding, and personal growth prove key to her redemption. One can argue that Snape in Harry Potter doesn't quite follow this redemption arc, and while many fans think his redemption proves just as valid, a case can be made against it. Snape arguably doesn't make any effort in his own redemption, and his love for Lily and grand reveal that 'he was actually one of the good guys all along' just doesn't seem to offer that same 'satisfaction' for lack of a better word as the other redemption arcs previously mentioned so much as it seems to play more into the role of a plot twist than a redemption arc. We don't see the same focus on growth and becoming a better person here. This begs the question- what makes a good or bad redemption arc and what differentiates a redemption arc from a plot twist?
|
Are Disability and Death Inextricable? | |
I appreciate you bringing attention to the gendered lenses writers (consciously or unconsciously) implement. I think drawing attention to these tropes and gendered roles can help us analyze how certain expectations come attached to the gender of a character, and ultimately, how have these roles come to reflect society, or vise versa. I don’t think writers are done exploring these tropes just yet, but I think it really pays to be mindful of them and how our preconceived notions can be influencing one’s writing for better or worse. | Men Written by Women: Dreamboats or Brutes? |
The show was ahead of it’s time in many respects. I particularly liked a fact that you pointed out — that characters weren’t as confined to generalized archetypes, and presented as more multidimensional. Shows– particularly shows designed for non-adult audiences — often can fall into the trap of pigeon holing their characters into one defining trait and running with that label for the sake of ease, or under the guise of preventing confusion. Children don’t fit into boxes, however, and I think younger viewers aren’t always given enough credit in being able to understand things aren’t always cut and dry, black and white, good and bad. Having characters present with differing arcs, conflicting interests, and moral disagreements within their own identities is something the show did well. Adding the broader representation (especially for it’s time!) really makes this show one of a kind for the nostalgia books, and contributes to it continually being re-watchable to this day! | Celebrating, Analyzing, and Resurrecting Fillmore! |
I couldn’t agree with you more! Great article and well said reply. Thank you