Brooklyn Nine-Nine: Sitcom Gold or Flash in the Pan?

During last year’s Comedy Central Roast of James Franco, the roasters took turns making fun of fellow roaster Andy Samberg and his upcoming sitcom Brooklyn Nine-Nine. Roaster Jonah Hill claimed it would easily be cancelled after five episodes. However, it was SNL alumni Bill Hader as the ‘President of Hollywood’ who captured the show’s cultural preconceptions perfectly. He commented on Samberg’s show by saying: “Funny cops…you’re always pushing the envelope, Andy”.

Admittedly, its easy to scoot past this show without notice. Thanks to its bizarre marketing campaign, the show appeared to be yet another Office-like satire devoid of laughs or thrills. However, the show, from the hilariously surprising pilot onward, transforms into a charming and blissfully entertaining sitcom. How does it do this? With good ol’ fashioned comedic timing. I know, this is relevant to all sitcoms – for there would be no sitcoms without this glorious invention.

However, Brooklyn Nine-Nine is the first sitcom, arguably, since Parks and Recreation to get this right. Despite my overwhelming praise, the question has to be asked: where is the tension in this article? Well, despite the show’s entertainment value, I still have a few gripes. Despite its overall quality, I fear it may not have what it takes to even complete three or four seasons. I looked back on the first season’s efforts (18 episodes released so far) to offer my analysis of this bumbling yet enthusiastic creation. To make it simple, I’ve decided to list the show’s shiny positives and debilitating negatives. Hopefully, by the end of this, I can reach something of an informed conclusion.

Positive: The Characters

Andy Samberg and Joe Lo Truglio in Brooklyn Nine-Nine

Without interesting characters, sitcoms can tear at themselves until they fall apart. Beyond the hype and monetary gain, sitcoms should always look to the future. With comedy being entertainment’s most subjective genre, the characters need to rise up and deliver what they’ve promised.

I may not be an expert on all of this, for my evaluation of this series may be entirely different to everyone else’s. However, agreeably, certain characters define particular shows. Ricky Gervais’ character David Brent single-handedly saves The Office from being mundane and cheesy (sorry fans). Lead characters can immediately become tiresome. Representing target markets or social circles, lead characters normally play it straight compared to the wacky supporting characters. In particular, Topher Grace’s character Eric in That 70s Show is an intellectual titan compared to his scraggly-haired counterparts.

In Brooklyn Nine-Nine, however, Samberg’s character Detective Jake Peralta is just as silly as the rest of his police precinct’s inhabitants. In the pilot episode, Peralta comes to terms with his slacker Police Captain’s retirement and his new Captain(Andre Braugher)’s introduction. Dealing with his bizarre co-workers accordingly, Peralta treats his and their lives like forgettable jokes. As the rough-and-tumble detective, his ego leads him into disastrous situations.

Touched upon succinctly by Sergeant Terry Jefferds (Terry Crews) during the pilot, Jake’s impulsive behaviour guides the first season. Thankfully, the show takes the ‘black police captain’ stereotype in a new direction. Acknowledging the archetypes’ seminal traits, the show balances dry wit and hysterical gags. Samberg and Baugher’s chemistry elevates this sitcom above most of its type. The robotic Captain and sprightly detective lead this bumbling team of morons admirably.

Thankfully, the casting directors hit their A-game with this particular series. Overcoming his shoddy movie choices, Samberg re-discovers his laugh-out-loud comedic chops. Before the pilot’s conclusion, Samberg’s overt charisma and baffling charm bring Peralta to the forefront of this straightforward sitcom. However, despite my praise, I can see how this series might descend into chaos and misery. Samberg’s comedic muscle flexing, despite elevating Brooklyn Nine-Nine above most sitcoms, can become tiresome.

Known for three minute sketches on Saturday Night Live (seriously, watch the Lonely Island/Michael Bolton music clip!), Samberg will have to push himself before he will be able to carry this award-winning sitcom. Fortunately, his Peralta and Holt’s awkward friendship immediately hits it stride. Braugher’s character, confirming the major difference between himself and most NYC Police Captains in the pilot, comes off as a necessary hindrance. His emotionless stare and stiff reactions become hilarious gusts of fresh air compared to Samberg’s gleeful antics.

Negative: The Story-lines

Andre Braugher in Brooklyn Nine-Nine

Despite the engaging characterisations and impressive comedic timing, the story-lines, in nearly every episode, fall flat. Admittedly, these words seem a little harsh. Sitcoms rely on their characters and actors much more so than their small and over-arching narratives. However, this show’s mysteries and sub-plots become afterthoughts.

In each episode, the story-lines lead the characters down simplistic paths. Pushing each episode forward, these stories become small, almost insignificant parts of a much grander vision. If anything, each episode’s plot serves to move these characters from one skit to the next. Each episode is broken up into multiple plot-strands and sketches.

The other lead characters – rounded out by ball-buster Detective Rosa Diaz (Stephanie Beatriz), Detective Charles Boyle (Joe Lo Truglio), and Detective Amy Santiago (Melissa Fumero) – are sent off to elevate each episode’s tiniest strands. From the pilot episode onward, Boyle’s love for Rosa becomes increasingly irritating. Hindered by annoying personal assistant Gina Linetti (Chelsea Peretti), Boyle’s charming actions kick off their heavy-handed sub-plot.

Unfortunately, Fumero’s talents are under-utilised throughout the first few episodes. Despite her inherent charm and noticeable beauty, her infatuation with Captain Holt becomes steadily tiresome. Despite her chemistry with the other characters, her sub-plots distract from Peralta and Holt’s more interesting story-lines. Despite the enjoyably light tone, the show might want to elevate its over-arching themes and narratives before season 1’s finale.

Producers Phil Lord and Chris Miller(21 Jump Street, The Lego Movie)’s touches rub off on the characters. Known for turning tired premises on their heads, this starkly impressive duo lends a gentle hand to many conventional plot-strands. Despite these issues, the actors lift these sub-plots above desperate and bland. Characters actors and guest spots become second nature to this witty and insightful sitcom. Lo Truglio, seen in many big-budget comedies over the past decade, becomes a sweetheart in the best and worst moments. Thrown at opportune moments, Boyle – beyond being one of the precinct’s many punching bags – is a nuanced comic relief.

Commenting on the characters’ races at random, the show embraces its multi-ethnic cast. Diaz, coming off as another Michelle Rodriguez clone, places her emotions in full view. Matched only by Crews’ ‘Expendable’ character (get it?), her emotional spirals become major set pieces. However, they still come off as insignificant sketches. The women are pushed aside. More could be given to Santiago and Peretti’s characters. They, like many female characters in police-comedies/dramas, fall below the Bechtel test’s dividing line. Hopefully, despite its frolic male characters, the show will avoid transitioning into a misogynistic farce (The Big Bang Theory, in spite of its commendable intentions).

Positive: The Comedy

Terry Crews in Brooklyn Nine-Nine

Touching upon a completely baffling situation, Brooklyn Nine-Nine is an insatiably engaging and enjoyable farce. With each sketch, despite their overall attachment to each story-line, certain characters become bumbling idiots and eclectic presences.

With contrasting characters and bizarre situations becoming the norm in this and Parks and Recreation, this type of TV comedy relies on spontaneity. Despite the overt predicability, each sketch becomes increasingly potent and hysterical. The comedic moments rely on awkward moments and quick wittedness.

Thankfully, Samberg’s talents are put to good use. Playing a disgraceful man-child, Samberg’s physicality and snappy timing become vital elements of this ambitious sitcom. Making fun of his co-workers, his accomplishments contrast seamlessly with his overbearing mistakes. In episode three, his winning streak comes to a grinding halt. His reactions, despite his inherent charms, become key to this episode’s success.

After giving bumbling Detective Hitchcock (Dirk Blocker) an almost unsolvable case, Peralta’s smugness provides necessary laughs. However, after Hitchcock returns triumphant, Peralta’s smile turns into a concerned, scornful look. Obviously, being a show set in police station, every scene becomes drenched in ironic humour. To continue on with more seasons, the show should stick to its actors’ charisma. Delivering enlightening surprises and catchy punchlines, Brooklyn Nine-Nine‘s talented ensemble can carry it through several more seasons.

Nowadays, many shows, whether they be explosive hits or miserable bombs, have the potential to be cancelled after season 1. It’s a difficult task to keep a major production afloat for extended periods. Studios in charge of these sitcoms rest entirely on viewership and capitalist ideals. To be fair, they, like everyone else, are just looking out for number one. However, some major series’, like the US version of The Office, don’t know when to quit.

Brooklyn Nine-Nine has real potential. From the impressive cast to the spot-on writing, this show’s glorious high points and charming moments separate it from others of its type. With preconceptions eventually boosting the final product, this laugh-out-loud production, despite needing several upgrades before reaching Parks and Recreation‘s status, should be able to succeed.

What do you think? Leave a comment.

Posted on by
Hi, I'm Tom Munday. I'm a Journalism graduate from Perth's Curtin University who's passionate about film, TV, music, theatre, and sport. Happy reading, folks!

Want to write about TV or other art forms?

Create writer account


  1. Steven Holloway

    This show is quickly becoming one of my favorite all time sitcoms.
    All of them make me LOL all of the time.
    This, Community, 2 Guys and A Gal.
    I also loved Friends, Seinfeld, Three’s Company, etc.
    But those show didn’t make me consistently make me lol like the my all time favorite sitcoms.

    • Anyone who has watched this and not found it very funny does not enjoy good comedy. Especially if someone has watched all of the 17 episodes. It started out tenuously funny and turned into laugh out loud comedy.

      • Nilson Thomas Carroll

        It’s leagues better than the rest of the comedy shows on Fox primetime right now…that being said, I hope they do tighten the writing a bit. Arrested Development still remains the greatest comedy tv show ; )

  2. I heard of the show before hand but it didn’t really catch my interest. One day I was just channel surfing, couldn’t find anything. Even went on demand and still couldn’t find anything interesting to watch, then just came across brooklyn 99 and said let me check this out and see what it’s all about. lol

  3. T Gonzales

    I think the superbowl ep and the ep with Craig Robinson are the best eps of B99.
    The sb ep being the best on for sure. Funny from beginning to the very end.
    It was a great surprise that Adam Sandler appeared in it as well. It’s great that his appearance in the ep was leaked in the commercials.

    • Donnetta Mcintire

      It seems like after the Golden Globes, this show has hit another gear. Not sure if the particular eps were filmed before the win or not but the show seems to be getting better and better since it, and it was good before.

  4. I just started watching the show. I’m on episode 3, catching up on demand. It’s pretty funny, I think I’ll keep up with the show.

  5. TillMan

    great cast and decent acting but the writing is mediocre. they are trying to hard to capture that Modern Family vibe. fire all the writers before the show gets canceled

    • Patrina

      Nothing against Modern Family, but I don’t see it trying to capture that Modern Family vibe at all.

  6. Andy Samberg will be able to save any episode with his ability ti think on the fly and time his words for the funniest possible statement. Overall, I think this show has a lot of great potential.

  7. The only way I see the show slipping is if it tries to get serious or gets too caught up in the romance with Peralta and Santiago. Letting them become a couple could spoil the show’s goofy, fun vibe.

  8. Erin Derwin

    Something I kind of like about this show is that it stays a sitcom. I love “New Girl” and I have “the feels,” but Brooklyn Nine Nine gives what it promises, laughs. It doesn’t try to be much deeper in that and if it stays that way I think it will last. It reminds me of “Community” in that way. Although “Community” has chances to get real/emotional it will quickly back away and be ridiculous. If Brooklyn Nine Nine keeps to that all will be good.

  9. Really enjoyed Samberg’s time on SNL and glad to see him move into a successful solo sitcom

  10. Samantha Leersen

    I’ve been hesitant to start this series because the snippets I’ve seen don’t really appeal to me. But this article has me reconsidering.

  11. “ …[I]t was SNL alumni Bill Hader as the ‘President of Hollywood’ who captured the show’s cultural preconceptions perfectly. He commented on Samberg’s show by saying: “Funny cops…you’re always pushing the envelope, Andy”.

    If this is a serious comment, there is a lack of a culture awareness of “funny cops” in both past (See Keystone Cops, Police Academy) and present (See The Closer/Major Crimes). Humor has been an element in police shows pretty consistently for quite a while. I think (and this reads as such) that this is humor along the lines of deadpan irony, because this would be nothing new.

Leave a Reply