A phenomenon is happening in game industry. We are demanding more and more games that gives us more freedom and possibility of choice – such as the Telltale games -, in which we can alter the storyline based on our choices. We are criticizing games that lead us through a path we can’t change. The Wolf Among Us is a game that evidenciates this need to choose, we go under the skin of an authority (Bigby) and face difficult choices the entire game that could change the course of the destiny of an entire community that is under our protection, and our relationship with it. We are demanding to be put against the wall and feel the weight of responsibility over our shoulders. What does it say about our society? Are we striving to connect so bad with others that we want to feel our every action can set off a chain reaction that affects us all? Or are you only become so individualistic that we want to feel in control of all of our experiences?
I think the driving factor of these games is that we get to choose the driection we take our character in so many different ways, whether it's simply a narrative decision (ie if we kill a character or not) or building the personality of a character through the dialogue options. We are essentially given authority within these games and it is reflective of making our own choices in real life.
Even so we are still only given a restriced amount of options throughout these games. There are four preset doialogue options (one of which is usually "...") and when we do have a really huge decision to make only two options are mostly given. We don't really get that much control over these characters when you look at the bigger picture, they just so happen to be the protagonist of The Wolf Among Us or The Walking Dead.
Finally, Heavy Rain would be an excellent game to look at for this subject because there are 20+ different game endings, one of which being that every playable character can die, hence our failings have consequences in this game. – Jamie White8 years ago
Until Dawn is so far the best representation of the "choose your own story" type of game. Your decisions leave the most impact and can greatly change the outcome of the story. The Wolf Among Us had a few consequences, to the story and how other characters behave toward you, but not so much. Dragon Age allowed choices in dialogue, but besides one major plot altering choice, there weren't much consequences either. Players may crave for more choices because they want to be more involved and lost in the gameplay. When you make a decision, and see the later consequence, and thus develop a reaction because of it, you've lost yourself to the story and you've ultimately have become emotionally invested in the characters. – Jmarie8 years ago
[Telltale Walking Dead Spoilers] I'm have mixed feelings towards Telltale's story driven games. I'm drawn into these games because it lets us build our own world. If we feel like our decisions have weight, we become more absorbed into the story. I was drawn to The Walking Dead because I knew that my choices had consequences. It makes moments even more moving when you feel that you were a part of it. Unfortunately, Telltale more often then not gives you the illusion of choice instead of the real thing. If you choose save a character because you see something in them (like a shot at redemption for Ben in TWD, or hope for recovery for Sarah in S2) then you feel betrayed by the game when in the next act they're killed out of your control. I don't believe it has to do anything with isolation or individualism, instead more about us wanting control over our games. – Aaron8 years ago