How often have you done this and do you think it slightly 'impedes' your own experience with the text? For example, I watched Forman's adaptation of One Flew Over the Cuckoo's Nest before reading the novel. Despite the book being a favourite of mine, it was rather difficult for me to envision the setting, the characters, the environment, and the overall world of the work without thinking of the adaptation. I couldn't get Jack Nicholson's depiction out of my head when I was trying to imagine who this McMurphy character was. Similarly, the same can be applied with Nurse Ratched, the Chief and the overall layout of the unit these patients were residing in.
I literally just had a conversation about this subject with a close friend of mine. He said he liked to read the book after watching the on-screen adaptation because he knows he generally would enjoy the book more. So, rather than ruin the movie-going experience, he enhances his reading experience. Good topic! – Jemarc Axinto10 years ago
I'm really interested in reading about this, and I agree that it is probably more beneficial to see the film adaptation before reading the novel, but I'd like to point out one stipulation that would benefit being looked into: What happens if the novel has already been read, or has been out for a long time before an adaptation discussion began. Just some food for thought, but great idea for an article. – Matt Collazo10 years ago
My friend and I were talking about this recently. It would be great to see some diverse examples of films that couldn't live up to the source material, as well as movies that exceeded expectations. – Amena Banu10 years ago
Awesome topic. Maybe, point out some of the adaptations you should read the books for BEFORE seeing it and which one you shouldn't read. For example, Inherent Vice - Before. Gone Girl - After. – Thomas Munday10 years ago
I really like this idea! Maybe have a sort of pro/con list for reading the book after watching the movie. I also like the idea of including examples of movies that exceeded expectations set by the book as a couple people have mentioned already. – ekeating10 years ago
Intriguing. We often complain about a film adaptation of a book , as it can never recreate our private images, it'd be interesting to read about the effects vice-versa, and whether doing it in the other order can enrich the book? – Aliya Gulamani10 years ago
I am very stubborn when it comes to this topic. I don't think I've ever watched a movie if it was adapted from a book I haven't read. It would definitely be a cool topic to read about if it were structured by title of book/movie and what the outcome of watching the movie before reading the book was. This could even be done as a collaborative piece with one author watching the movie before reading the book and the other other doing the opposite. – AlexandraRose9 years ago
This is a very personal and subjective experience. Some people may find difficult not to recreate the movie's images in their heads when reading the book. Some people may be able to read the book without any "interference" from the impact the movie has left in them. – T. Palomino2 years ago
List of great contemporary short stories. I read a lot of science fiction and often encounter great short stories. Many authors have fine collections: Arthur C. Clark, Fred Pohl, Larry Niven, Isaac Asimov, etc. A couple years ago I read "The Hard SF Renaissance" which had many good stories. Hard to pick a favorite but maybe Ted Chiang's "Understand" about a guy who has brain damage and is given an experimental drug to heal it. He turns into a super-genius. Nancy Kress's "Beggars in Spain" story was later expanded into a series of books. It's about genetically modified people who no longer need to sleep.
Very interesting idea. I think short stories are a very under-appreciated form. You've mentioned several science fiction short stories but I don't think you should limit yourself just to sci-fi. For a comprehensive list of great contemporary short stories you should try to look across all genres - or if you want to focus only on sci-fi, make sure the title of the article reflects that. – ekeating10 years ago
This is a very interesting topic, because, similar to short film, these shorter pieces rarely generate the hype or special attention they may deserve. One thing I caution is to avoid listing these great stories by title alone; make sure you're able to provide specific reasoning as to what makes said stories so great, independently or as a genre, etc. This way, it become something much more than a comprehensive list of great works, but one that you could argue for as standing out from the rest, which is immediately more interesting to read and digest. Good luck! – Matt Collazo10 years ago
Two other great short story writers of Fantasy and science fiction are Ursula K. Le Guin and Neil Gaiman. I recommend Ursula K. Le Guin's "The Ones Who Walk Away From Omelas" as one of her best. The language is colorful and rich and the story is entirely prose, no dialogue at all. – Travis Kane10 years ago
Did 60s literature do anything more than tell us about what the 60s were like or are there actual life lessons to be learned about from the adventures they went on and the stories they wrote.
There's plenty of talk about gender and sexuality play out in Fifty Shades of Grey. What could be even more interesting is looking at how class plays out. Could one argue that Anastasia Steele fulfills a class fantasy by getting involved with the much richer Christian Grey? Does the so-called American Dream revolve around the obtainment of wealth? How does the exposure to such enormous wealth influence the wealthy characters? How are individuals with lower incomes portrayed – in a way that ignores the humanity of these individuals, or in a way that recognizes the privilege of being white and upper class? Could be an interesting topic to explore.
While this topic is listed under literature, the film version could certainly also be explored.
Could be interesting to look at Anastasia's socioeconomic place in the world; a presumably upwardly mobile recent college grad, albeit in a less economically lucrative degree. What does the story imply about someone of her class in this situation? – Mariana10 years ago
Classist fantasies are power fantasies.Given the dom-sub relationship in the book/film which manifests and is fairly evident throughout, I really don't think it is a topic which needs contextualising or elaborating on. Sorry! – Yama14410 years ago
When our kids were small, we owned lots of books and were regulars at the library, so a lot of picture books went by. Some were so wonderful the kids kept them, or bought copies for themselves as adults. Among those were several which were all about the art rather than the story. Would love to read a piece about the greatest picture books.
Since printing has become accessible to the general public, so many people are making children's books... – LaurenCarr10 years ago
It could be interesting to see how the art contributes to the story, rather than being all about the art rather than the story. Especially with kids, pictures make scenes much easier to visualize. It could also be interesting to see how picture books now include more inclusive stories, such as the inclusion of LGBTQ families in children's picture books - could these picture books be considered great by breaking ground in LGBTQ representation? – aileenmaeryan10 years ago
A helpful resource for this topic would be "Words About Pictures" by Perry Nodelman. He discusses the significance of the artwork in classic picture books such as "Where The While Things Are." – Kewalder10 years ago
It is actually a good topic, I love picture books. True that some books are more great pictures and art than the story itself, and they can be as good a reading for adults as it is for children. – suepri9 years ago
Discuss the idea that Scott Westerfield's novel, "Afterworlds", condones dyadic withdrawal to an extreme extent. Dyadic withdrawal is a situation in which a person gets into a romantic relationship and then drifts away from many of his or her friends. In the novel, the main character spends a lot of time with her S.O. They write together, eat almost every meal together, and often sleep at each other's apartment. However, the main character seems reluctant to spend time with any of her friends or anyone other than her S.O. In the end, they break up and get back together, but they seem to think that there is no problem with the isolated nature of the relationship.
Now that "Sons of Anarchy" is over, it would be interesting to explore any books out there about the MC world. I know there is plenty of non-fiction. Let's focus on fiction. So far all I've come across is a ton of romance.
I'm not sure if this fits exactly, but there is a light novel series called Durarara!! by Ryohgo Narita that has to do with Japanese gangs, and there is a headless motorcycle rider involved. While it may not be exactly what you're looking for, it may open up a new pathway to look toward. – BethanyS10 years ago
It is so fictional it's silly. My husband is in a motorcycle club. When I see these far from realistic displays of MC's I can't sit through it. – LaurenCarr10 years ago
Like movie remakes… but in books? From my understanding, in a way, there is–Stephen King's publisher has issued long-form versions of books originally released with substantial edits. I was still reading King when some of these came out, and the two unedited versions I read, both of books I knew well in their original published form, were badly bloated, having benefited greatly from the edits which shortened length and deleted scenes and subplots which did not contribute to the whole.
It's unlikely to happen often, though. Most authors' edited work is pretty close to the original they turned in. The author (or his/her heirs) own the rights to their books for 70 years after death, so it's not like another author can write a brilliant update without violating copyright.
I know of one instance that may be worth researching. The Wheel of Time series by Robert Jordan. While the series was not remade per say, Brandon Sanderson was (possibly still is in a way) responsible for completing the series. The series is large, spanning fourteen books, but Sanderson comes into the writing scene about halfway through book twelve, and the different writing style shows, which may be something to look into when considering a piece like this. Again, the Wheel of Time series was not necessarily remade, though in my opinion, the difference in writing style could make a book or a book series remade in some way.
– BethanyS10 years ago
Does Shakespeare fall under this category? Before Shakespeare's version, Hamlet had been retold by several people. Along with Hamlet, his plays Othello, Romeo and Juliet, and The Winter's Tale (to name a few) were borrowed from several sources. One could compare the earliest version of Romeo and Juliet with the one Shakespeare wrote and comment of the changes made and how that affects the story as whole. – Amanda Dominguez-Chio10 years ago
I think examining Shakespeare would be a good place to start. Many people might think he came up with completely original content, but many elements of the plays, if not most of the plots, were taken from other stories. Also, Tolkien's Unfinished Tales and The Silmarillion might be worth thinking about. It contains idea and content that gives alternate details about Middle Earth and its major figures. Tolkien never finished The Silmarillion, and both books were published by his son Christopher Tolkien after his passing. While these books might not be considered remakes, readers can speculate what Middle Earth would have looked like if Tolkien had reconciled the materials found in these books. – S.A. Takacs10 years ago
There are cases where something like a "directors-cut" version, or other versions of a book is released, would those count? – DancingHelix10 years ago
Simone de Beauvoir's "The Second Sex" has only recently received an unabridged English translation, and Sylvia Plath's journals have recently been published, unabridged, for the first time. – Kristian Wilson10 years ago
Book adaptation has been going on since the Medieval period. Any author who writes a book about King Arthur participates in such an act. Anyone who adapts literature from the Ancient and Medieval period does this, whether it be book, film, or any other media. The question really is can one write a book adaptation of a book written in the last century? Most books based on older classic books usually go unheard of from what I see. – Travis Kane10 years ago